diff --git a/launcher/LaunchController.cpp b/launcher/LaunchController.cpp
index 2c76fee4f..a72cc58b1 100644
--- a/launcher/LaunchController.cpp
+++ b/launcher/LaunchController.cpp
@@ -258,29 +258,8 @@ void LaunchController::login()
                 continue;
             }
             case AccountState::Expired: {
-                auto errorString = tr("The account has expired and needs to be logged into manually. Press OK to log in again.");
-                auto button = QMessageBox::warning(m_parentWidget, tr("Account refresh failed"), errorString,
-                                                   QMessageBox::StandardButton::Ok | QMessageBox::StandardButton::Cancel,
-                                                   QMessageBox::StandardButton::Ok);
-                if (button == QMessageBox::StandardButton::Ok) {
-                    auto accounts = APPLICATION->accounts();
-                    bool isDefault = accounts->defaultAccount() == m_accountToUse;
-                    accounts->removeAccount(accounts->index(accounts->findAccountByProfileId(m_accountToUse->profileId())));
-                    if (m_accountToUse->isMSA()) {
-                        auto newAccount = MSALoginDialog::newAccount(
-                            m_parentWidget, tr("Please enter your Mojang account email and password to add your account."));
-                        accounts->addAccount(newAccount);
-                        if (isDefault) {
-                            accounts->setDefaultAccount(newAccount);
-                        }
-                        m_accountToUse = nullptr;
-                        decideAccount();
-                        continue;
-                    }
-                    emitFailed(tr("Account expired and re-login attempt failed"));
-                } else {
-                    emitFailed(errorString);
-                }
+                if (reauthenticateCurrentAccount())
+                    continue;
                 return;
             }
             case AccountState::Disabled: {
@@ -304,6 +283,34 @@ void LaunchController::login()
     emitFailed(tr("Failed to launch."));
 }
 
+bool LaunchController::reauthenticateCurrentAccount()
+{
+    auto button =
+        QMessageBox::warning(m_parentWidget, tr("Account refresh failed"),
+                             tr("The account has expired and needs to be reauthenticated. Do you want to reauthenticate this account?"),
+                             QMessageBox::StandardButton::Yes | QMessageBox::StandardButton::No, QMessageBox::StandardButton::Yes);
+    if (button == QMessageBox::StandardButton::Yes) {
+        auto accounts = APPLICATION->accounts();
+        bool isDefault = accounts->defaultAccount() == m_accountToUse;
+        accounts->removeAccount(accounts->index(accounts->findAccountByProfileId(m_accountToUse->profileId())));
+        if (m_accountToUse->isMSA()) {
+            auto newAccount =
+                MSALoginDialog::newAccount(m_parentWidget, tr("Please enter your Mojang account email and password to add your account."));
+            accounts->addAccount(newAccount);
+            if (isDefault) {
+                accounts->setDefaultAccount(newAccount);
+            }
+            m_accountToUse = nullptr;
+            decideAccount();
+            return true;
+        }
+        emitFailed(tr("Account expired and re-login attempt failed"));
+    } else {
+        emitFailed(tr("The account has expired and needs to be reauthenticated"));
+    }
+    return false;
+}
+
 void LaunchController::launchInstance()
 {
     Q_ASSERT_X(m_instance != NULL, "launchInstance", "instance is NULL");
diff --git a/launcher/LaunchController.h b/launcher/LaunchController.h
index f1c88afb7..33aedb063 100644
--- a/launcher/LaunchController.h
+++ b/launcher/LaunchController.h
@@ -74,6 +74,7 @@ class LaunchController : public Task {
     void login();
     void launchInstance();
     void decideAccount();
+    bool reauthenticateCurrentAccount();
 
    private slots:
     void readyForLaunch();